+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +

EStAL 4/2018 – Special Issue: Ex Post Monitoring and Evaluation
The last issue of 2018 of the European State Aid Law Quarterly is dedicated to the European Commission’s follow-up of approved State aid measures, monitoring their implementation by Member States and evaluating their economic impact, as part of the State aid Modernisation reforms that begun in 2012. Our articles cover the state-of-the-art of State aid Evaluations and how they could look in the future; what changes when moving from ex ante to ex post control in the Monitoring of State aid; a detailed analysis of the Impact of State Aid on Competition; and the national Experience of the United Kingdom with State Aid Evaluation.

Two enormously important cases receive expert annotations: The General Court’s ruling on Case T‑356/15 Hinkley Point C (especially important for those daunted by its 736 paragraphs!) and the Court of Justice’s Case C‑579/16 P FIH Holding.

We also have the latest State aid news from Belgium, the EEA and EFTA States, Poland and Spain.

To close off, returning to our regular sections is the Event Report on the high-level conference Economics of State aid Control: Where Law and Economics Meet, organized by Lexxion Publisher and Vrije Universiteit Brussel, in cooperation with E.CA Economics, which took place on 5 October 2018 in Brussels.


View all articles of EStAL 4/2018 here.

To stay up-to-date, sign up for our newsletter!

+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +

The European State Aid Law Quarterly cordially invites recent PhD graduates to submit articles based on their thesis, defended after 1 January 2012. The winning contribution will be awarded with a one-year subscription* to the European State Aid Law Quarterly and with an invitation to attend the 2016 Autumn Conference on State Aid Law** in Madrid, Spain.

* Worth of €599, excl. German VAT.

** Estimated worth of €785, excl. German VAT.

<!--[if gte mso 9]> <w:lsdexception locked="fal

Publication frequency: quarterly
approx. 100 pages
ISSN 16 19-52 72

Annual subscription
Special Offer 2-for-1


EStAL - European State Aid Law Quarterly

EStAL was established in 2002 as the first pan-European publication for State aid law and is still recognized as the leading journal in its field today. EStAL’s successful philosophy is to serve as a forum for open dialogue and reflection on State aid law and policy for and between academics, judges, Commission and Member States officials and private practitioners. This philosophy shows in the composition of the editorial board and translates to the selection of authors and commentators and EStAL’s circle of readers in particular. EStAL accordingly offers a balanced mix of high-quality legal analysis, concise information and pointed opinion pieces on State aid law and policy from diverse backgrounds to the benefit of all those dealing with State aid issues on a regular basis.

EStAL provides you quarterly with a review of around 100 pages, containing articles, case studies, jurisdiction of both European and national courts as well as communications from the European Commission.


Managing Editors

Caroline Buts, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Brussels

José Luis Buendía Sierra, Garrigues, Brussels


Editorial Board

Josef Azizi, Former Judge at the General Court of the European Union

Andreas Bartosch, KRB Kemmler Rapp Böhlke, Brussels

Andrea Biondi, King's College London

Rose D'Sa, European Economic and Social Committee, Brussels

Leo Flynn, European Commission, Brussels

Leigh Hancher, Tilburg University, Allen & Overy, Amsterdam

Michael Honoré, Bech-Bruun Law Firm, Brussels

Thomas Jaeger, University of Vienna

Christian Koenig, Center for European Integration Studies, Bonn

Koen Lenaerts, Court of Justice of the European Union

Arjen Meij, Former Judge at the General Court of the European Union

Phedon Nicolaides, College of Europe and Maastricht University

Michael Schütte, Schütte Law Brussels

Adinda Sinnaeve, European Commission, Brussels

Country Correspondants

Austria Birgit Haslinger
  Johannes Kepler University, Linz

Belgium Laura Parret
  Houthoff Buruma, Brussels

Bulgaria Ilko Stoyanov
  Schoenherr, Sofia

Czech Republic Ivo Janda
  White & Case LLP, Prague

Croatia Marko Maček
  Croatian Bank for Reconstruction and Development, Zagreb

Cyprus Michalis Kamperis
  Ierotheou, Kamperis & Co. LLC, Nicosia

Denmark Michael Honoré

Brech-Brunn Law Firm, Brussels

EFTA States and EFTA Community Monica Wroldsen
  Norwegian Government, Oslo

Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania Daiga Lagzdina
  Ardenis Ltd., Riga

Finland Ilkka Aalto-Setälä
  Partner at Borenius Attorneys Ltd, Helsinki

France Nicole Coutrelis
  Coutrelis & Associes, Paris

Germany Christoph Arhold
  White & Case LLP, Berlin

Greece Antonis Metaxas
  Metaxas & Associates, Athens

Hungary Anikó Keller
  Szecskay, Budapest

Italy Sara Gobbato
  BM&A Studio Legale Associato, Treviso

Ireland Christine Fauroux
  Maples and Calder (Dublin)

Luxemburg Philippe-Emmanuel Partsch
  Arendt & Medernach, Luxemburg

Malta Yana Haber
  Ministry of Finance, Floriana

Poland Przemyslaw Kamil Rosiak
  KPMG, Warsaw

Portugal Philipp Melcher
  MLGTS & Associados, Lisboa

Romania Anca Jurcovan
  Tuca Zbarcea & Asociatii, Bucharest

Slovakia Peter Hodál
  White & Case LLP, Bratislava

Slovenia Matej Kavčič
  Kavčič, Rogl & Bračun, Ljubljana

Spain Juan Jorge Piernas López
  University of Murcia

Sweden Pamela Hansson
  Kastell Advokatbyrå AB, Stockholm

The Netherlands Emma Besselink
  Allen & Overy LLP, Amsterdam

United Kingdom George Peretz
  Monckton Chambers, London


EStAL Review Process

The articles featured in each issue of European State Aid Law Quarterly (EStAL) are
as well requested submissions as unsolicited ones. All undergo the review process as followed: Each article is circulated among the full board and reviewed and refereed by the board members.

Article Submission

It is understood that EStAL accepts for print submissions of excellent quality only. All publications must demonstrate clearly that they are sufficiently distinct from the status quo of discussions among the informed State aid community, in particular through sufficiently broad footnoting and citations, and aim at advancing those discussions.

Whereas opinions and case notes may be more pointed, articles in particular must take clearly visible notice of pre-existing literature and jurisprudence, even if the positions expressed there are to be rejected by the author of the submission at hand. Likewise, submissions relating to very recent developments require less footnoting and citation than submissions relating to familiar topics.

Publications not living up to this quality standard will be rejected by the editorial board in the pre-publication review process.




Caio Weber Abramo
Tel.: +49 30-81 45 06-17


(orders, enquiries, returns)


Cristina Gîrloanƫă
Tel.: +49 30-81 45 06-12

StateAidHub byLexxion7

CoReBlog Banner 300px Neu


Publication frequency: quarterly
Subscription: € 442,-
ISSN 16 19-52 72

Further information
This website uses Google Analytics for internal evaluation purposes. To prevent Google’s collection and use of data: click this link. An opt-out-cookie will be implemented. Please find more information in our data privacy information